Simple "midi mode" Switch

One of my synths sends its notes as midi to its sound generators AND to the outside world via midi-out. Often if you use a sequencer this is not what you want. I’ve always been able to set my synths (the ones with a keyboard) in the ‘midi’ mode, which meant that they only send midi to the sequencer which would then sent it either back to the synth or to some other synth. In this way any of my keyboards can be used as a master keyboard to play any of my synths as long as the sequencer sends the incoming midi data to that synth. This is a standard way of working with sequencers. Well, I recently got a synth that does not know such a mode. So what happens is that it plays a note, sends the midi data to the sequencer, gets this echoed by the sequencer and plays the note again. A perfect little feedback loop!? Because of the small time delay this results in a flanging effect which can be nice but it also means that your synth uses twice the number of voices it normally would.

So this can be solved by either having the sequencer not echo the midi data OR getting the synth to ignore the echoed midi. The prior is cumbersome if you are playing and recording and replaying and disturbs the ‘creative process’. The synth does allow to shut off the midi input, but that is also cumbersome because it means diving into a few menus and changing the settings for all midi-in channels. So … I made a little foot pedal that is set between the sequencer and the midi-in of the synth and can stop or pass thru the midi-in data. Doing this with one foot I hope is a much more convenient solution to the problem.

Phew, a long introduction for such a simple device!

If only Moog would update the firmware so that I would not need this switch. Why does a modern keyboard NOT have a “midi mode”. All my +20 year old keyboards do have this !

One afterthought:
There is something you have to pay attention to if you use a switch like this. If you break the connection after a note was started and before the note off event is received by the synth, that note will keep playing. So you need to press the switch between note events coming from the sequencer.

4 Likes

that is a pretty ingenious work around there . I have an answer to the problem , for myself anyway . not having enough money to by new moog gear :frowning_face: .

4 Likes

Old Moog gear isn’t exactly much cheaper :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:.

5 Likes

I made a small change to the switch. The problem with the switch as it was is that it being a toggle switch there was no clear indication which position it was in. And although in the right position the midi data was not passed by the switch, that is not always apparent. This switch is meant to prevent midi events from being echoed, so only the voice count being used by the synth engine or an audible flanging effect are a sign that the unwanted echo is still there. But then it struck me that when the switch is not passing the midi data to the synth so when it is diverting the midi data into the Void I could use the diverted midi signal as a sign! Just by adding an LED to the switch. So whenever that LED is flashing midi data is not going to the synth. This also meant that I needed to mark one of the DIN ports as IN and the other as OUT. Prior to adding the LED that was of no importance. Here are 2 pics showing the new situation. There is no need for a series resistor as that is in the device sending the midi data (220Ohm).

DIN connector 1 is the input, DIN connector 2 is the output.

3 Likes